Michael Parks
Pastor Abin Cooper
John Goodman
Joseph Keenan
Melissa Leo
Sara
Michael Angarano
Travis
Kyle Gallner
Jarod
Nicholas Braun
Billy-Ray
Kerry Bishé
Cheyenne
Stephen Root
Sherrif Wynan
Matt Jones
Deputy Pete
Kevin Alejandro
Harry, the Tactical Agent
Ralph Garman
Caleb
Anna Gunn
Travis' Mother
Kevin Pollak
ASAC Brooks
Betty Aberlin
Abigail
Jennifer Schwalbach Smith
Esther
Patrick Fischler
Agent Hammond
Damian Young
Agent Carol
David Marciano
Agent Eccles
Kaylee DeFer
Dana
Ronnie Connell
Randy
Alexa Nikolas
Jesse
Cooper Thornton
Plastic Wrap Man
James Parks
Mordechai
Haley Ramm
Maggie
Elizabeth Tripp
Melanie
Molly Livingston
Fiona May
John Lacy
Travis' Father
Catherine McCord
News Reporter
Deborah Aquila
Mrs. Vasquez
Joey Figueroa
Route 9 Friend
Rose Colasanti
Believer
Carryl Lynn
Believer
Alyssa Petersen
Believer
Bill Cleavelin
Believer
Sadey Paige Nifong
Believer
Scott Nifong
Believer
Gary Sievers
Believer
Marc Blucas
ATF Sniper
Molly Hagan
Janet Keenan
Kevin Smith
Prisoner (voice)
Edward Janda
ATF Agent
Shawn Driscoll
Believer
Marnie Shelton
Believer
Ernest O'Donnell
ATF Agent
Dylan Belardinelli
ATF Agent
Morgan Bertsch
Young look-a-like (uncredited)