Lindsey Morgan
Stephanie
Michael O'Keefe
Mr. Donaghy
Will Sasso
BaBa
Berto Colon
Agent Conrad
Michael Iacono
Young Tim
Reggie Lee
Danh 'The Chinaman' Tran
Piper Watts
Meghan Donaghy
Taylor Colwell
Mary Battista
Scott Wolf
Tommy
Robbie DeRaffele
Celtic Perlins
Izzy Batinkoff
Cool Girl
Betsy Beutler
Debbie Battista
Johnny Calabro
Gambler
Robert Capelli Jr.
Vinnie Vegas
Clark Carmichael
Ref Chris
Natalie Cassell
Casino Patron
Rebeka Choudhury
Priya
Julie Claire
Kim Donaghy
Julia Ford Collier
Sasha
Curtiss Cook
U.S. Attorney
Nick Cordero
Pete Ruggieri
John Dinello
Skeptical Cop
Dana Drori
Sara
Daphne Gaines
Katie Carrick
Jeff Girault
Broadcaster
Charles Grady
Task Force Officer
Chloé Guerin
Mary Battista (voice)
Sabina Kelley
Runner #2
Kglory
Self
Maurice Little
Basketball Game Spectator
Bob Lloyd
Father Mulhearn
David Lowe
Gambler
Eric Mabius
Tim
Ken Maharaj
Doctor Raj
John Marigliano
Joey Giordano
Paul J. Martino
Johnny
Steven McCormack
Frat Guy
Peyton Monaghan
Young Baba
Arthur J. Nascarella
Mr. M
Sid O'Connell
Han James
Kevin Pajak
Young Tommy
Michael A. Pierce
Tough Guy
Sarah Pribis
Amber
Joey Rullo
Officer Joe
Lia Russo
Cute College Girl
David Sheridan
Casino patron
Jenson Smith
Teri
David Walcott
Sixer
Michael DeBarge
Park couple (Uncredited)
Frank Sorgenti
Gambler (Uncredited)